Tuesday, April 16, 2013

Science and Mythology

Every civilization, since the very first civilizations at the beginnings
of history, needs creation stories/myths. Some of the best ones are from
the Bible, Greek and Norse mythology, and from the various native
American tribes. Without a credible creation story that helps us
undertand who and why we are here, we are, in effect, lost and
purposeless.

Most of us in the so-called modern world choose to place our faith in
the scientific method, at least in part because we are born into a world
largely shaped by scientific discoveries. So it's only natural that we
find the big bang, multiverse and cyclic universe theories compelling
and credible. And in their own way, they help us understand where we fit
in the grand scheme of time and space, why life exists, and how our own
personal self came into being. Creation theories, including the big
bang, say something (necessarily incomplete) about where our world is
heading (i.e., what is the ultimate end, and will things just get
started over again?) And they can help us feel like we are part of
something bigger, something that has existed before our personal self,
and will endure either "forever" or a very long time after we are
personally gone.

Whether human societies in the very distant future embrace science, the
scientific method, and scientific creation theories - we just can't know
that. In other words, if we're going to be open to a new idea right now,
we have to see science and the scientific myths we believe today, as
part of a long historical process. But this process, contrary to much
modern thinking, does not have an irreversible direction. Evolution,
including human evolution, does not evolve along a guaranteed pathway,
with the assurance of indefinite progress towards ever greater
scientific knowledge. We just don't know the future of evolution, or
whether the human race has a place in it, esp. given that 99% of species
that ever lived are extinct.

The progress we have seen over the last couple centuries simply could
not have happened without massive easy to exploit supplies of cheap
energy. That fossil fuel age is coming to an end, baring a totally
unexpected miracle discovery of carbon-free, near unlimited energy. So
21st century societies will be forced to live in a world with much less
energy than we've become used to. [I'm no happier about this than anyone
reading this post]. So, to simplify a bit, we can't have high energy
physics without lots of high energy. We can't run CERN on artisanal
windmills. And we won't be able to support the "unending" progress of
science and the scientific mythology that we tend to like, if global
civilization itself is struggling to get by on far less energy. So I
suspect that science will continue on, but with progress going much more
slowly by mid-century than what we have become used to. How the myths,
especially the creation myths, will change will be fascinating to watch
(but I don't expect to live that long)...

Thursday, April 4, 2013

Exceptionalism

Have you ever noticed that whenever anyone publicly questions American Exceptionalism, they are immediately attacked by the right wing?  Let's explore what exceptionalism really is.

What is commonly though of as exceptionalism is this: The United States is the one essential nation, a force for good, a global power that makes the world a better place.

But what is exceptionalism, after one takes a deeper look?  What it really is is a set of related beliefs, never publicly stated:

  • The citizens of the United States, especially the wealthier, whiter more conservative ones, are god's chosen people.  They have been selected by their Christian deity to lead, rule and police the world, intervening wherever American power and authority is challenged.  It's therefore necessary, from time to time, for the chosen people, the exceptional people, to use military force to repel what is perceived and portrayed as evil in the world.
  • Exceptionalism is a special kind of entitlement.  Believers in exceptionalism imagine that Americans, privileged Americans, are entitled to consume one fourth of the world's oil and about one third of the world's other natural resources.  Why?  Because Americans are god's chosen people, and shouldn't the chosen people be entitled to a bigger helping of earth's bounty, even if we have to fight wars against evil to protect what's rightfully ours?
  • Exceptionalism is an excuse to commit violence on the less powerful people of earth, killing, maiming and torturing as directed by the leader of the exceptional people, the US President.  
  • Exceptionalism is a justification for failing to agree to UN treaties or the authority of the International Criminal Court.  Why?  Again, because we are the exceptional people, and we recognize no superior authority but our own deity, and only conservative Christian US leaders and very powerful American industrialists are empowered with the ability to understand what this deity wants us to do.
  • In order to remain the exceptional nation, the wealthiest Americans must not allow the US government to in any way lighten the heavy burden placed upon the poor, the sick, many of the young, the unemployed.  All government assistance creates weakness and dependency which weaken the exceptional nation.  Yet there is one exception to this rule: It's perfectly OK, indeed mandatory, for the government to provide a big helping hand to those who are already quite wealthy because the wealthy citizens have proven they are the most chosen of the deity's chosen people.  [And besides, they are major campaign donors.]
So in a very real sense, the US public is exceptional: Exceptionally deluded in thinking we have been selected to rule the world and that American values and our system of politics and economics may rightfully be imposed on the rest of the world whenever we see fit to do so.  Exceptionally deluded in thinking that there is some deity who has committed to magically protect the United States from harm, as long as the country remains a conservative Christian stronghold that limits the rights of gays, women, people of color, immigrants, and any other group out of favor with god's chosen political Party, the Republican one.  Indeed, we are truly an exceptional people... and we will be exceptionally disappointed when it all starts to fall apart.